Tuesday, October 10, 2023

The history of conflicts in the region of Palestine is as old as the oldest history records and comes down to the present day intact and with many unresolved issues. I saw a map that someone published this morning dating from 1947 and showing Palestine as a 'unified' state. Prior to that it had been a part of the Ottoman Empire - since the 16th Century - becoming a British protectorate only after WW1.

Any student of the history of this region will know that 'ownership' of the lands we know as Palestine has changed hands many times; at one stage or another being a part of Ancient Egypt, Ancient Israel and Judah, the Persian Empire, the Roman Empire, the Crusaders, a number of Muslim Caliphates, with the Ottomans bringing up the rear. It has rarely been in control of its own destiny.

So waving a map from 1947 is not going to cut it in terms of who should be doing what now. We are talking about the last five minutes after all, in a game of changed ownership and boundaries that is several thousand of years old.

I don't aim these remarks at the most recent Palestinian occupiers, who have a valid claim to live there, though hardly one that has a deep historical imprimatur. A two state solution seems like the only solution to me, but the current outbreak of war will set that back decades.

But I'd like everyone to truly give peace a chance.

No comments: